Assumption Surfacing and Knowledge Audit

Description

Makes the team's unstated assumptions explicit and sorts them by what is known, believed and unknown, before they shape research design and product decisions.

Assumption surfacing and knowledge audit, drawing on Mason and Mitroff's strategic assumption surfacing and on David Travis's advice to research practitioners, makes the beliefs that underlie a product plan explicit before they silently shape research. The team writes down assumptions about users, problems, behaviour, value and feasibility, then classifies each by evidence strength (known with evidence, believed, unknown) and by the consequence of being wrong. A knowledge audit then checks existing research, analytics and support data to see what is already known, preventing duplicate studies. High-risk, low-evidence assumptions become research questions. Rigour comes from writing assumptions as testable statements, requiring evidence references for anything marked 'known', and revisiting the inventory as research reports.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Effort
Hours

Steps

  1. Team workshop — 30 minutes: Each participant writes 20–30 statements on sticky notes starting with "Users…" or "We know that users…" No filtering. All assumptions included, however obvious they seem.
  2. Evidence audit: Researcher leads evidence audit for each statement. For each: "What's the evidence?" Possible answers: (a) strong evidence from prior research, (b) weak evidence from anecdote, (c) no evidence — assumption only.
  3. Categorise: (1) High confidence / high importance → monitor but don't research. (2) Low confidence / high importance → priority research question. (3) Low confidence / low importance → deprioritise. (4) Contradicted by evidence → immediate action.
  4. Convert to research questions: Each category-2 assumption becomes a research question. The research plan follows from this audit, not from a predetermined method preference.

Sources

  • Think Like a UX Researcher (David Travis)
  • Just Enough Research (Erika Hall)

Also known as

  • Assumption mapping
  • Knowledge audit
  • Assumptions workshop

Categories

  • Research Operations
  • Research Design & Rigor