Applied Cognitive Work Analysis (ACWA)

Description

An engineering form of cognitive work analysis that carries domain analysis through to display concepts via five linked, traceable artefacts, from a functional abstraction network to presentation designs.

ACWA was built to close the gap between cognitive analysis and design. It produces a chain of five artefacts: a Functional Abstraction Network of domain goals, processes and means; cognitive work requirements (the decisions and monitoring each node demands); information and relationship requirements; representation design requirements, which also serve as test specifications; and presentation design concepts as storyboards or prototypes. Each artefact links back to the previous one, so every display element can be traced to a domain function and decision. The work proceeds in expanding spirals, with knowledge elicitation used to bootstrap the network, and a quality worksheet checks the functional network. Worked applications include military command and control decision support. Its rigour lies in traceability; its cost is heavy documentation and the need for skilled modellers.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Effort
Months

Steps

  1. Bootstrap a Functional Abstraction Network of goals, processes and means from documents and expert elicitation, and check it with the quality worksheet.
  2. Overlay the cognitive work requirements (decisions, monitoring, planning) at each network node.
  3. Derive the information and relationship requirements each decision needs.
  4. Write representation design requirements that state how each relationship should be shown; these double as evaluation criteria.
  5. Produce presentation design concepts as storyboards or prototypes.
  6. Iterate in expanding spirals across the domain, preserving links between all five artefacts.

Sources

  • Handbook of Cognitive Task Design (Hollnagel, 2003)

Also known as

  • ACWA
  • Functional Abstraction Network (FAN)
  • ACWA case studies

Categories

  • User Research
  • Task Analysis & Cognitive Modelling