Anticipatory Failure Determination (AFD)

Description

Inverts failure analysis by asking how one could deliberately make the system fail, then uses resource analysis to find and block those routes.

Listed in the treatise's borrowing matrix for systems engineering, AFD applies TRIZ to failure. Instead of asking 'what might go wrong?', which is limited by imagination and optimism, analysts take a subversion stance: 'how could we make this fail?' They then search for the resources (substances, fields, time, user behaviours, system states) in the system that would enable that failure, and design out the routes. For UX, the subversive question becomes 'how would we design this flow to make users lose money, leak data or give up?', a stance that surfaces dark-pattern-like risks and abuse cases that conventional reviews miss.

Attributes

Loss type
Unmigrated
Effort
Hours

Steps

  1. Define the undesired outcome (for example user unknowingly shares location).
  2. Reformulate as an invention problem: how could we deliberately cause it?
  3. Brainstorm subversion scenarios using existing system resources and user behaviours.
  4. Check which scenarios are already possible in the current design.
  5. Design countermeasures that remove the enabling resources.
  6. Re-run subversion on the revised design.

Sources

  • Lost Methods in UX — A Complete Treatise (Gopinath)
  • Kaplan S, Visnepolschi S, Zlotin B & Zusman A (1999) New Tools for Failure and Risk Analysis: Anticipatory Failure Determination and the Theory of Scenario Structuring. Ideation International
  • Altshuller G (1984) Creativity as an Exact Science
  • Kaplan, Visnepolschi, Zlotin & Zusman, New Tools for Failure and Risk Analysis: Anticipatory Failure Determination and the Theory of Scenario Structuring (1999), Ideation International
  • Savransky, Engineering of Creativity (2000)

Also known as

  • AFD
  • Subversion analysis
  • TRIZ failure analysis
  • Inverted TRIZ failure analysis
  • Anticipatory Failure Determination

Categories

  • Accessibility
  • Human Factors & Error