Analytic Bracketing (Gubrium and Holstein)

Description

Alternate during analysis between how people build meaning in talk and which institutional discourses and resources shape that building, documenting each against the other.

Analytic bracketing is not phenomenological bracketing of the researcher's assumptions. It is a constructionist analytic move that alternates between two foci. First the analyst sets aside the 'whats' of everyday life to document the 'hows': the discursive practice by which participants build accounts, categories and identities in interaction. Then the analyst brackets those 'hows' to document discourses-in-practice: the institutional categories, rules and resources locally available, and how they are distributed and regulated. Each is referred to while documenting the other, and unlike ethnomethodological bracketing the alternation continues throughout analysis rather than only at the start. Later work extends it to narrative reality, distinguishing narrative work from narrative environments. There are no mechanical rules; the risk is collapsing one side into the other.

Attributes

Loss type
Unmigrated
Stage
Discovery
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Collect naturally occurring talk, interviews or documents from an institutional setting.
  2. Document how participants build their accounts: categories used, identities claimed, how descriptions are made to count (discursive practice).
  3. Bracket that and document the discourses, categories, rules and constraints available in the setting (discourses-in-practice).
  4. Move back and forth, linking each finding about talk to its institutional conditions and vice versa.
  5. Write up both the constitutive and the contextual picture and show where they shape each other.

Sources

  • The SAGE Handbook of Qualitative Research (Denzin & Lincoln, 2017)

Also known as

  • Constructionist analytics
  • Interplay of discursive practice and discourses-in-practice

Categories

  • User Research
  • Qualitative Analysis & Synthesis