Analogical Reasoning Analysis for Onboarding

Description

Analyses interface metaphors as structure mappings from a known source domain, identifying correct, missing and misleading relational correspondences to design onboarding that transfers knowledge.

Gentner's structure-mapping theory explains analogy as mapping relational structure, not surface features, from a familiar source to a new target. Goswami showed that even young children reason analogically when they know the source domain's relations. Interface metaphors (desktop, folders, wallet, cart, inbox) work the same way: users import the source's relations, and the analogy succeeds when relations hold and misleads when they do not. The method lists the source's key relations, maps each to the target system, and classifies them as valid, absent or misleading. Onboarding and design then reinforce valid mappings, explicitly flag misleading ones, and use worked comparisons that make relational similarity salient, which research shows improves transfer. Testing checks whether users predict system behaviour from the metaphor correctly.

Attributes

Loss type
Unmigrated
Stage
Design
Data
Mixed
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Test analogical transfer for any new interface concept: teach users the concept in one interface context (source).
  2. Present an unfamiliar but structurally analogous interface (target).
  3. Measure: how much does source learning transfer to target performance?
  4. High transfer (> 70% performance improvement vs. control) = the analogy is structurally sound.
  5. Low transfer = the analogy's structure doesn't match the target domain.

Sources

  • Wiley-Blackwell Handbook of Childhood Cognitive Development — Usha Goswami
  • Gentner, Structure-mapping: A theoretical framework for analogy (Cognitive Science, 1983)
  • Goswami, Analogical Reasoning in Children (1992)

Also known as

  • Structure-mapping analysis
  • Interface metaphor mapping

Categories

  • User Research
  • Cognitive Psychology & Perception