Agent-Host-Environment Analysis of UX Harm

Description

Decomposes a UX harm into agent (pattern), host (user susceptibility), environment (platform, context) and mechanism to target interventions at each.

The epidemiological triad holds that disease results from interaction of an agent, a susceptible host and an environment that brings them together. The treatise uses this structure throughout: a dark pattern is the agent, the user the host, the platform and situation the environment, with cognitive bias exploitation as the mechanism of action and modifying factors altering susceptibility. Structuring a harm this way prevents single-cause thinking ('users should read more carefully') and maps interventions to each vertex: remove or weaken the agent (redesign), protect the host (literacy, defaults, accessibility) and change the environment (platform rules, regulation, timing). The roach motel case study in the treatise is an exemplar of this analysis.

Attributes

Loss type
Unmigrated
Effort
Hours

Steps

  1. Define the harm outcome precisely with a case definition.
  2. Characterise the agent: pattern features and the cognitive or structural mechanism it exploits.
  3. Characterise hosts: which users are susceptible and why (literacy, stress, age, disability).
  4. Characterise the environment: platform, context, incentives, time pressure.
  5. Gather evidence for each element from research, logs and literature.
  6. List interventions per vertex and estimate feasibility and impact.

Sources

  • Lost Methods in UX — A Complete Treatise (Gopinath)
  • Rothman KJ, Greenland S & Lash TL (2008) Modern Epidemiology
  • Gordis L (2014) Epidemiology. 5th ed

Also known as

  • Epidemiological triad
  • Agent-host-environment model

Categories

  • Epidemiology & Population Health