Affordance Analysis

Description

Maps the action possibilities an interface offers against those users actually perceive, separating real affordances from signifiers to find hidden and false affordances.

Gibson defined affordances as action possibilities that exist in the relation between an actor and an environment. Norman brought the idea into design and later clarified that what designers control are signifiers: perceivable cues that communicate an affordance. Affordance analysis operationalises this distinction. For each element the analyst records what actions are actually possible, what actions are signalled, and what actions users perceive. Gaver's taxonomy then classifies the result as a perceptible affordance, a hidden affordance (possible but not signalled, such as an undiscovered swipe) or a false affordance (signalled but not possible, such as decorative text styled like a link). Rigour comes from checking perception empirically, through first-click tests, prediction prompts or observation, rather than relying on designer intuition, and from considering the actor's capabilities, including motor and sensory impairments.

Attributes

Loss type
Active
Data
Mixed
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Inventory interactive and non-interactive elements on the screens or physical product under review.
  2. For each element record actual possible actions and the signifiers that communicate them.
  3. Ask 5-8 users to predict what each element does or where they would act to achieve a goal, without instruction.
  4. Classify each element as perceptible, hidden or false affordance using Gaver's taxonomy.
  5. Prioritise hidden affordances on critical paths and false affordances that cause wasted actions.
  6. Redesign signifiers and re-test predictions, including users with different motor and sensory capabilities.

Sources

  • The Ecological Approach to Visual Perception
  • Design for How People Think
  • The Design of Everyday Things (Don Norman)
  • Goldstein, E. B., Sensation and Perception
  • Gibson, J. J., The Ecological Approach to Visual Perception (1979)
  • Whalen, J., Design for How People Think (2019)
  • Sensation and Perception (Goldstein)
  • Ecological Approach to Visual Perception (Gibson)
  • Design for How People Think (Whalen)
  • The Inquiry Series, Ch 11 — Perception — Before Cognition

Also known as

  • Affordance Theory
  • Affordance mapping
  • Perceived affordance analysis
  • Affordance analysis
  • Affordance and signifier audit

Categories

  • User Research
  • Cognitive Psychology & Perception