Active Intervention

Description

A tester sits with the participant and probes their understanding at planned points during tasks, revealing how their mental model develops.

In active intervention a member of the test team sits in the room and deliberately probes the participant throughout the session rather than waiting for spontaneous think-aloud or a closing interview. Typical probes ask what the participant would do next and why, or, on choosing a menu option, how they understand the menu structure at that moment. Because probes recur across tasks, the method shows how the participant's mental model forms and changes, and gives diagnostic insight into the causes of problems. It is especially productive early in design and with prototypes. Its rigour depends on planning probe questions and points in advance and phrasing them neutrally. It deliberately trades away timing and independence: time-on-task and assistance counts are invalid.

Attributes

Loss type
Renamed
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Define the test goals and the mental-model questions you need answered.
  2. Plan probe questions and the points in each task where they will be asked.
  3. Seat a test team member next to the participant and explain that questions will be asked during tasks.
  4. Probe at the planned points (next step and why, current understanding of structure or terms), avoiding leading questions.
  5. Record answers alongside behaviour, noting how explanations change across tasks.
  6. Analyse answers for mental-model gaps and causes of problems.

Sources

  • A Practical Guide to Usability Testing (Dumas & Redish, 1999)

Also known as

  • Active intervention testing
  • In-session probing

Categories

  • User Research
  • Usability & Evaluation