AcciMap Analysis

Description

Map an accident's contributory factors onto six system tiers, from government policy down to equipment, and link them by cause and effect to find where intervention is needed.

AcciMap extends Rasmussen's risk management framework into a graphical analysis of the failures, decisions and actions behind an accident or incident. Contributory factors are placed on six hierarchical tiers: government policy and budgeting; regulatory bodies and associations; local area government planning and budgeting; technical and operational management; physical processes and actor activities; and equipment and surroundings. Cause-effect links are drawn within and across tiers, so a frontline error is traced back to the management, regulatory and policy conditions that shaped it. A hierarchical evaluation then identifies the significant factors and the levels where intervention is needed. Unlike Swiss Cheese or HFACS, which classify failure types, or STAMP/STPA, which models control structures, AcciMap is a free-form systemic causal map whose value lies in drawing attention away from blaming the last person to act. It has been applied in aviation, road transport and mining.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Stage
Post-launch
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Collect data on the accident, incident or failure from reports, logs, interviews and documents.
  2. Identify contributory factors: failures, decisions, actions and conditions.
  3. Place each factor on one of the six tiers, from government policy to equipment and surroundings.
  4. Draw cause-effect links between factors within and across tiers.
  5. Evaluate the map hierarchically to identify the significant factors and the tiers where interventions would have most effect.
  6. Translate findings into recommendations aimed at each relevant tier, not only the frontline.

Sources

  • Handbook of Human Factors and Ergonomics (Salvendy & Karwowski, 2021)

Also known as

  • AcciMap

Categories

  • Strategy & Collaboration
  • Systems & Complexity